D.Louise makes lifeproof jewellery with a lifetime guarantee against fading, and plants a tree with every order. We started testing its store in 2022. In February 2023, it asked us to rebuild the store, and we tested the rebuild too.
The challenge
D.Louise ran on a standard Shopify theme. It couldn’t show the brand or the quality of the jewellery, and the conversion rate was lower than the products deserved.
A new design was the obvious answer, but a redesign on opinion is a gamble. Every change had to prove itself on real shoppers before it stayed.
Testing from the start
Before any rebuild, in 2022, we tested what shoppers responded to, one idea at a time: free shipping and returns shown in the cart, “Olivia’s Favourites” on category pages, a mini image gallery, a product finder under the hero, best-seller tags, a shipping timer, “The D. Louise Promise” and clickable benefits.
- Design by opinion→Changes tested on real shoppers
- A standard theme→A custom theme, tested 25 times
A rebuild, proven by 25 tests
In 2023, we built a new visual identity and a custom Shopify theme, fast and built for search. Then we ran 25 A/B tests of the new design against the old site.
Most tests, especially on the listing pages and cart, showed a 90 to 100% probability that shoppers preferred the new design. Only then did it stay.

Three more years of tests
In 2023, we added an order countdown, product customisation, landing pages for ads and Gorgias chat, and A/B tested the checkout journey. Based on the data from one test, launched on 13 March, the conversion rate improved by 11%.
Then came gift packing, a luxury box with ribbon or a gift bag, and an automatic upsell. In 2025, we built “Styled by You”, customer photos for each product, and put live the winners of another team’s tests: a top bar, category swatches on the homepage, a new collection page and payment options on the product page.
Results
The tested rebuild paid off across the store, and the testing carried on to the end of 2025.
- Total sales up 24%.
- Average order value up 17%.
- Add-to-cart rate up 9%.
- Sales from search up 33%.
- Returning customers’ conversion rate up 24%.
- One 2023 test: conversion rate up 11%.
